Civil Society Against Tortures. The Cases of Torture in Armenia
29.06.2016
11:00
“It is very hard to explain to my clients that if torture was used against him, it is necessary to apply, fight and demand that the perpetrators be prosecuted and one out of 10 agree to do that,” Advocate Hayk Alumyan said during the discussion at Media Center.

The speaker said that in order to detect the cases of torture, first of all, the tortured  person should be interested in this issue, be consistent and inform about it.

“With regard to torture, I have achieved a victory at the ECHR in three cases, but if my clients were ready and araise about the acts of torture and fight together with me, it would not be 3 but 30 victories," the expert said and added that our society is impermissibly tolerant of torture.

Haykuhi Harutyunyan, Head of “Protection of Rights without Borders” NGO, said that up to 2015, 12 rulings were adopted concerning Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights that is about the prohibition against torture. 

“One case was about the torture, 9 cases were over the inhumane treatment, 2 cases were over the lack of effectiveness of the investigation,” she said. 

Harutyunyan said that the cases of tortures were mostly explored by the Public Monitoring Group. As an example she mentioned the data of 2013, when as a result of the studies of the monitoring group 324 cases of bodily injuries were revealed among 1431 prisoners, 363 reports were submitted concerning them by the group.

Advocate Hayk Alumyan said that if ECHR adopted 12 rulings it does not mean that there were 12 cases of torture in Armenia.

“It means that only this many people were consistent in the process of claiming justice,” Alumyan said.

Harutyunyan said that ECHR Committee on Tortures has adopted strengthened control against Armenia, as they came to a conclusion that the satate does not take enough steps to prevent such cases.

Hayk Alumyan added that the violence against persons are primarily used to obtain confessions. Despite all the efforts of human rights activists, these confessions continue to be the basis of a guilty verdict by the judges. "As they say, demand breeds supply. If there is a demand in the court to seize any evidence through the use of torture at any cost, it is obvious that there will be torture and confession obtainers." 

The speaker stressed that the only interested party today, revealing the torture are journalists and civil society. As regards the prevention of torture, it is very difficult to measure it. But there is one indicator that after considering it, we can say if the struggle against torture is good or not, but in general there is no struggle.

"Last year, how many people have been convicted for torture - zero, two years ago - zero, and earlier - zero again ... and so on. This is the main indicator, which shows that there is no fight against torture, and the persons or representatives of civil society, who are trying to fight, everything is done that these people fail to achieve success," Alumyan added.

Arevik Sahakyan, Program coordinator at “Media Center”

To contact the author please send an email to areviksahakyan@mail.ru

Videos
Print Friendly and PDF
More Press Releases
Reasons and Tendencies of Hepatitis Transmission in Armenia
16.08.2018
12:00
Media Center, Yerevan, in 2017-2018 Positive People Armenian Network NGO conducted a research in Yerevan, Gyumri, Vanadzor, Hrazdan, Sevan, Gavar, Martuni and in Armavir aimed at early disclosure of virus hepatitis B and C among population and raising awareness.
Defense Field State Procurement Contain Intense Corruption Risks: Expert
26.07.2018
14:00
On July 26 Artak Manukyan president of National Center of Public Policy Research presented the monitoring results of 2017-2018 defense field state procurements at Media Center.
Media: New Authorities, Tendencies to be Concerned About
25.07.2018
12:00
Manipulation, campaigns, disinformation, fake sites, all this has always been in media. It’s the scales we witness currently that enables media experts to label the situation as critical.
“The Obstacles Facing the Monitoring Group and Current Problems Relating to Violation of Human Rights in Penitentiary Institutions”
25.07.2018
11:00
After the velvet revolution the ministry of justice sticks to the same position and keeps hindering the group's activity the same way", stated Nare Hovhannisyan, member of the public monitoring group in conducting public control in RA ministry of justice at July 25 Media Center discussion.
The Conditions of Russian Military Base Armenian Stay Should be Clarified
23.07.2018
13:00
At July 23 Media Center discussion on “Unrest over Panik Incident”, Artur Sakunts, head of Helsinki Citizens’ Assembly Vanadzor Office labelled July 17 Panik incident on behalf of Russian military as terror act against the local population.
Follow us on social networks
Registration of events
Services
Videos
Armenia-Turkey Events