The ECHR Judgement Was a Blow to the Criminalization of the Denial of the Armenian Genocide
The judgment of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in the case of Perinçek v. Switzerland met the demands of Armenia which was involved in the trial as a third party. The judgement, though, can hardly be called a victory.

Earlier on October 15 the European Court of Human Rights passed a judgment on the case of Perinçek v. Switzerland. The court decided that the right of the freedom of expression of the Turkish ultranationalist Doğu Perinçek was restrained when the latter was found guilty of racial discrimination for calling the Armenian Genocide “an international lie.”

Yerevan, however, believes the judgement proposes new prospects for the Armenian side since from now on Armenians can file lawsuits against people who may obviously deny the Armenian Genocide, thus offending the Armenian identity.

“The ruling defines Armenians have the right to defend their identity. And the Genocide has had a tremendous impact on the Armenian identity. One can hardly find an Armenian family which has not been affected by the Genocide in the Ottoman Empire. Thus, the ruling creates a platform for the protection of the Armenian identity,” believes international rights expert Ara Ghazaryan.

Following the ECHR judgement Armenia’s Prosecutor’s Office released a statement that the requests of the Government of Armenia have been fully met by the European Court of Human Rights.

“As a third party we aimed to clear the ruling of the lower chamber of any wording that may lay doubt on the fact of the Armenian Genocide,” said Arman Tatoyan, Deputy Minister of Justice.

The judgement, Tatoyan said, fixes that the court is not eligible to give definitions and estimates regarding the true existence of the Genocide, which was reflected rather badly in the previous decision.

Avetik Ishkhanyan, however, believes it is Perinçek who won. “It is a fact. Whatever you may say, we now see that ECHR qualified Switzerland's actions as a limitation of rights. This is a great blow to the criminalization of the denial of the Armenian Genocide. ”

The Deputy Minister disagreed and said the court did not consider charging Perinçek a phenomenon controversial to the European Court’s precedential right.

 “The court fixed that the Swiss law was misused against Perinçek. Outlawing the denial of the Armenian Genocide and charging are legally equal but within the European Convention only,” Tatoyan said.

Ishkhanyan describes the international recognition of the Armenian Genocide along with the trial at ECHR as a political process. “It is a political process. The fact that ECHR failed to study thoroughly Perinçek's statement to reveal his real reasons comes to prove it. Perinçek is a nationalist politician who intentionally chose Switzerland to make such a statement. The court, however, appears to have bypassed this fact,” said Ishkhanyan.

Arshaluys Mghdesyan, Editor-Coordinator

Print Friendly and PDF
More Press Releases
“RA NA Snap Elections Pre-Election Period Monitoring Primary Results”
On November 22 Media Center hosted a press conference on “RA NA Snap Elections Pre-Election Period Monitoring Primary Results”. The speakers were Varuzhan Hoktanyan, project director at Transparency International Anti-Corruption Center, Sona Ayvazyan, executive director at Transparency International Anti-Corruption Center and Alik Petrosyan, project coordinator at Transparency International Anti-Corruption Center.
Priority Issues and Measures Taken to Improve Prison Education
In penitentiary institutions in Armenia there are still a number of issues related to convicts’ education rights implementation.
NGO Law Amendments in the NGO Objections Spotlight
November 8 Media Center discussion dealt with State Revenue Committee new bill which envisages full visibility of NGO financial reports.
Ex Convicts’ Reintegration Issue in Armenia
The reintegration issue of ex convicts starts at the moment when the sentenced person enters penitentiary institution.
Hovhannes who spent 6 months in custody but finally found justice tells about his struggle, the violence and suppressions he was subjected to.
“The person who lost freedom lost hope for life. He doesn’t know when he will be released and what awaits him.”
At the beginning I did not figure out how long I will stay in prison. In Nubarashen penitentiary the cells are in a poor condition. The walls are covered with mould, insects and even scorpions entered the cells. The air was stuffy. Sometimes 14 people would stay in a cell equipped for 12.
Follow us on social networks
Registration of events
Today at Media Center
December 12, 11:00
Press Conference
Human Rights in 2018: Round-up of the year
Press Releases
Armenia-Turkey Events